By Maryanne Welton
Replacing an aging residential hotel near downtown San Jose, Calif., Casa Feliz Studios was developed in 2009 with 60 new apartments by First Community Housing (FCH). The energy-efficient apartments serve extremely low-income residents — 35 percent with developmental disabilities — and are located in a run-down neighborhood of Victorian houses interspersed with deteriorating 1960s apartment buildings. At less than half an acre, the tight infill site required a creative and efficient design.
The building’s crowning glory is San Jose’s first green roof, which was engineered to maximize stormwater retention, holding 60 to 80 percent of rainwater on the roof. Preliminary meetings with the city public works department realized a requirement to replace and upgrade the existing storm sewer to a 100-year-flood capacity at an estimated cost of more than $300,000. The owner and architect, Rob Wellington Quigley, FAIA, researched using a green roof as a way to mitigate the stormwater requirement. Paul Kephart of Rana Creek provided FCH with design assistance using this “revised” technology.
Preliminary analysis showed that the installation of a green roof could reduce the stormwater runoff to such an extent that only a new 10-year-event pipe would be required. This could be accomplished at the same cost or less than the 100-year-storm sewer “upgrade.” A series of meetings with various city departments was necessary to convince city officials that the green roof could indeed reduce the building’s stormwater runoff.
The high cost of upgrading the insufficient storm drain system made the decision to add green roofs economically feasible, but the green roofs add much more to the building than simple stormwater retention. They provide habitat for wildlife, increased roof insulation and cooling, longer roof life due to the blocking of ultraviolet rays, and reduced ambient heat reflected from the roof (which increases the efficiency of the photovoltaic system). The non-irrigated plantings bloom during the mild winter and spring rain, and die down during the long, warm summers.
OWNER/DEVELOPER: First Community Housing
ARCHITECT: Rob Quigley Architects, FAIA
GENERAL CONTRACTOR: Branagh Construction
LEED CONSULTANT: Simon & Associates
GREEN ROOF CONSULTANT: Rana Creek
CIVIL ENGINEER: Carroll Engineering
MODULAR GREEN ROOF SYSTEM: BioTray
GREEN ROOF MONITORING: Agilewaves
Sedum ‘album murale’
Sedum rubrotinctum ‘Jelly Bean’
Sedum ‘acre aureum’
Sedum ‘Borshi Sport’
Dudleya ceaspitosa (or) pulverulente
TOP LEVEL ROOFS (HAND-SCATTERED SEED)
Layia platyglossaThe use of organically grown plants and a pesticide-free growing medium protects the quality of any water that percolates into the site or drains into the public storm drain system. The plants are a mixture of annual and perennial sedums, grasses and wildflower species that provide a healthy habitat for birds, insects and butterflies. The plant materials were chosen to thrive in hot, polluted air and shallow soil mixtures. They are typically found in California’s native serpentine grasslands, which feature shallow, nutrient-poor soils.
There are five different green roof areas, totaling 5,375 square feet. One is partially covered with photovoltaic panels. The rooftop wildlife habitat is not intended for tenant recreation or public viewing, but three small garden roofs at each upper floor are visible from apartments, hallways and decks, which will display vibrant colors and textures throughout the seasons for the daily enjoyment of building occupants.
Each roof includes a waterproof membrane covered with 3 to 6 inches of specialized soil mixtures. The upper roofs were planted with scattered seeds. Rana Creek was involved in developing a biodegradable modular planting system made from coconut shells, called BioTray, that was used for the project. For the lower roofs, the plants were grown at Rana Creek’s nursery and transported to the site in 4-inch deep BioTray baskets, which provide both erosion control and thermal resistance.
The green roofs at Casa Feliz provide a continuous layer of R-30 insulation over the building spaces below, eliminating the thermal breaks that result in energy losses in standard wood-frame roof assemblies. The mass of the living roof combined with the water retention capacity minimizes “thermal shock” to the building from varying high and low roof temperatures, thereby moderating temperature fluctuations inside the building and reducing the need for heating and cooling. The roof provides free evaporative cooling on hot days and high insulation value on cold days, keeping the roof at a relatively stable temperature.
Although there are additional costs for installing a living roof, particularly for increased structural load, Jeff Oberdorfer, executive director at First Community Housing, estimates that it added about half of a percent to the overall construction cost, which was offset by eliminating the required storm drain upgrade.
To track the performance of the living roof, FCH installed an Agilewaves resource monitoring system. A weather station measures rainfall at the site, and water flow gauges at the roof drain measure runoff, enabling the developer to calculate the actual water retention capacity of the living roof and demonstrate the reduced burden on the City’s storm drain system. This performance data will be used to educate the building industry and policy makers about the benefits of green roofs with the goal of encouraging wider spread adoption.
As San Jose’s first development with a living roof, the project acts as a prototype and educational resource for other municipalities, developers and communities. Casa Feliz “has been a model for incorporating water conservation features in affordable housing,” said Oberdorfer. The project team hopes that the success of Casa Feliz’s living roof experience will plant a seed to inspire others to plant their own rooftop gardens.
Maryanne Welton has been a project manager with Rob Wellington Quigley, FAIA, for 34 years, leading design teams on a variety of affordable housing and civic buildings.
Article courtesy of Green Roofs for Healthy Cities (GRHC), and was originally published in GRHC’s Living Architecture Monitor: www.livingarchitecturemonitor.com.